Trump vs. Harris: The economic topics to watch during tomorrow's debate

Sep 09,2024

On Tuesday night, Kamala Harris and Donald Trump will meet for the first time — literally, as they’ve never met in person before — for a high-stakes debate in Philadelphia with economic issues likely to be front and center.

What is well known is how each side is likely to attack the other on fiscal issues. How they respond is where it could get interesting.

Former President Trump is highly likely to once again charge that Harris is a communist, echoing a favorite and baseless line in recent weeks that he's running against "Comrade Kamala." Vice President Harris is sure to shoot back with charges that Trump's plan could tip the country into a recession and send prices through the roof via his tariffs plans.

Both candidates could be flustered by directly wrestling with these charges, as they've often campaigned recently in scripted campaign appearances, speeches, or interviews with friendly interlocutors.

Still, what few observers are expecting is a high-minded discussion of economic plans.

"Anybody who goes in expecting probing questions and deep discussion on economic policy tends to leave disappointed," Stifel’s chief Washington policy strategist, Brian Gardner, recently noted of debates.

Trump vs. Harris: 4 ways the next president could impact your bank accounts

Trump vs. Harris: The economic topics to watch during tomorrow's debate
Will they shake hands? Former US President and Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump and Vice President and Democratic presidential candidate Kamala Harris. (Associated Press) (ASSOCIATED PRESS)

Instead, the expectations are for a tense confrontation that is likely, perhaps more than anything else, to be most memorable for the name-calling and how each responds. Trump and President Joe Biden refused to even shake hands when they met in June — and the tone this week is likely to be similar.

The back-and-forth Tuesday night is also expected to cover a wide variety of terrain, from abortion to immigration to Trump's continued focus on election lies.

But here's some of the pocketbook issues to watch.

'Comrade Kamala'?

One of former President Donald Trump’s favorite digs these days is to talk about "Comrade Kamala" Harris.

It’s a blatantly false nickname that Trump has nonetheless stuck with in recent weeks as an apparent way to signal his overall charge that Harris is a candidate of the far left who would wreck the economy if she wins.

Harris has, it seems, spent much of the last week preparing to rebut the charge with a series of moves to moderate her economic platform.

Last Tuesday, Harris announced a small business plan that included a 10-fold increase in tax credits for new entrepreneurs and a pledge to cut government red tape.

Then, on Wednesday, there was Harris's announcement that she would split with Biden and back a top long-term capital gains rate of 28%.

Finally, on Friday, it was the release of a letter from more than 90 business leaders endorsing Harris, including the current CEOs of Yelp, Box, and Chobani, as well as an array of big-name former executives.

Then this week, her website debuted an issues page with the first chapter devoted to her "opportunity economy" plans.

Kamala Harris proposes tax credit for first-time home buyers. What about Trump?

Trump vs. Harris: The economic topics to watch during tomorrow's debate
Vice President and Democratic presidential candidate Kamala Harris arrives to speak at a campaign event in North Hampton, N.H., on Sept. 4. (JOSEPH PREZIOSO/AFP via Getty Images) (JOSEPH PREZIOSO via Getty Images)

The series of releases aimed to underline how, as Harris put it in a recent speech, her White House would be one that "leads to broad-based economic growth and ... creates jobs, which makes our economy stronger."

Harris also outlined her overall debate message during a break in preparations on Saturday in Pittsburgh, saying: "It’s time to turn the page on the divisiveness. It’s time to bring our country together."

Whether she can make that case and also convince voters of her business bona fides with Trump standing just a few feet away is something that will be closely watched.

How does Trump respond to the charge of a 'national sales tax'?

Trump may also need to offer new details Tuesday night on his plans for tariffs.

The former president has promised to levy duties of 10% to 20% on US trading partners and higher rates of 60% on China if he is returned to the Oval Office.

That could lead to additional costs of up to $3,900 for a typical family each year, according to an estimate from Brendan Duke of the left-leaning Center for American Progress.

The Peterson Institute for International Economics has also run the numbers and found a somewhat smaller tab, but the Harris campaign has seized on that $3,900 stat to charge again and again in recent weeks that Trump is proposing something akin to a "national sales tax."

What are tariffs, and how do they affect you?

It’s a charge that Trump has repeatedly brushed off in recent weeks, but he could be directly confronted with the issue by Harris or the debate moderators — ABC’s David Muir and Linsey Davis.

And Harris may be looking for such a direct confrontation. In a recent New York Times interview , Hillary Clinton said she's spoken with Harris, and her advice is Trump "can be rattled. He doesn’t know how to respond to substantive, direct attacks."

Trump vs. Harris: The economic topics to watch during tomorrow's debate
Former US President and Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump smiles during a town hall moderated by Fox News in Harrisburg, Pa., on Sept. 4. (MANDEL NGAN/AFP via Getty Images) (MANDEL NGAN via Getty Images)

Trump is unlikely to back away from his plans, based on a recent appearance at the Economic Club of New York. The former president doubled down on his tariff ideas in that speech, even in the face of persistent business world worries about the instability that might come with another series of Trump-led trade wars.

Will the muted mics lead to more substance?

All told, "we expect tariffs and taxes to feature prominently as topics of discussion," the analysts at Raymond James wrote in a recent preview for clients. But they noted that both candidates could be light on details, with Harris in particular incentivized "to remain light on policy specifics where she can through November."

Perhaps the question is whether the fight over debate rules will force the candidates to provide more detailed answers from the candidates when these topics come up.

After weeks of back-and-forth, the Harris campaign has assented to mics that are muted when it’s not a candidate’s turn to speak. Each candidate will be allotted two minutes to answer each question with an additional minute set aside for possibles follow-ups, according to the published plans for the debate.

It was a set of rules first agreed to in the June debate in part to provide candidates with time and space to explain their policies without interruption.

What remains to be seen is if the candidates use the time to break new ground on their policies from taxes to energy to fighting inflation.

"Any incremental new information we get is helpful, but I'm holding my breath that we're going to learn a lot," Gardner added in a recent webinar appearance.

Ben Werschkul is Washington correspondent for Yahoo Finance.